Chacey Poynter: I called him after that I told him that my Jeep was stuck and that I needed him to come help me. SHANE MEEK: Do y'all have a relationship? Robert and Chacey Poynter, whose maiden name is Chacey Morman, lived together in Royse City. Garza told the court he couldn't have murdered Robert Poynter because he was tending to a sick animal on the family farm. Chacey Poynter: He's goofy. Michael Burk: The victim was sitting in the driver's seat He's got an entry wound approximately right here on the temple. Prosecutor Jeff Kovach doesn't buy any of it. However, Michael was charged with murder for the role she apparently played at this time. Where he was just ready, you know, to get a divorce. Morning clouds will give way to afternoon sunshine. Peter Van Sant: What were you thinking going into trial? This week on Reasonable Doubt, the team takes on the Raul and Cathy Sarinana were sentenced to death for abusing Would love your thoughts, please comment. [Spoiler], Recap and Conclusion of In/Spectre Season 2 Episode 2. She said that she had called her husband for help, telling him that her Jeep was stuck in the mud. Jeff Kovach: The question is which one of those stories does she want us to believe? Chacey Poynter [in tears]: When I'm awake, I see his face. Chacey Poynter, 29, was being held in the jail Tuesday in lieu of $500,000 bond on one count of conspiracy to commit murder, after being transferred to the facility from the Rockwall County Jail. Prosecutors were hopeful, too, that they would prove Chacey wanted Robert's money and that she was the mastermind. It's a true farm road. Michael initially refused to give statements, yet the fact the weapon was found alongside seemingly one of his shirts a month later in a field less than a mile from the crime scene implicated him. SHANE MEEK [bodycam video]: At a friend's? Peter Van Sant: Did you conspire to have your husband murdered? He had pleaded not guilty. Peter Van Sant: And that suggested what to you? Nicholas Cron to slash her husband to death with a box cutter. SGT. SGT. Willow Martin: 5 Fast Facts You Need to Know. They called it search and rescue, but it was really more search and recovery, Poynter told the Dallas Morning News in 2005. SHANE MEEK [bodycam video]: Breathe for me, Miss Poynter. Jeff Kovach: I think it's pretty clear it's about killing Robert Poynter. Peter Van Sant: Chacey told me that you always had Robert's heart. Robert was hopeful the marriage could be saved. The Poynter family now focused on Chacey. Chacey Poynter: We started seeing each other in December of 2007 and I was pregnant by May of 2009. He wasn't home as much. SHANE MEEK [bodycam video]: All right look up at me. Officers also searched wooded areas near the home and other locations where Garza has lived, according to police. Meek details not of the shooting, but of the state of her marriage: SGT. / CBS News, [This story originally aired on January 18. SHANE MEEK [bodycam video]: Alright, well give me a second, my partners need to speak to me. She claimed she only wanted Garza to hurt her husband, not kill him. Jeff Kovach: There's no way Michael Garza was ever going to get Robert Poynter out on that road alone. Peter Van Sant: The next day he is killed. CHACEY POYNTER: I loved him. Though Chacey initially claimed that Michael was leaving the state when Bob was killed, her . Kriti Mehrotra August 26, 2022 The September 9, 2016, homicide of beloved community servant, career firefighter Robert Louis Poynter III, is a case that stunned not only the state of Texas but also the entire nation to its core. A firefighter with the touch of a gentle giant. having it is almost like having part of his presence which is comforting in a way and painful in another. Breathe fast like that you're not helping yourself, OK? You always had this underlying feeling that Even if he had to walk through fire, somehow that man would make it through. Calvin Grogan: There were plenty of text messages after the life insurance beneficiary designation change occurred in April, indicating that Chacey Poynter was looking for somebody that would take care of Robert. Chacey Poynter: He wore the cologne that he wore on our wedding day, and he hadn't worn it since. From the moment police arrived at the scene, they were skeptical of Chacey's story of what happened. Peter Van Sant: What do you think she's made up her mind about? In her trial before a jury in 2019, Chacey Poynter was accused of using sex and deceit to coerce Michael Garza, her accomplice in the murder, into carrying out all the dirty work. Information provided led to a search warrant of a home in Quinlan, Texas, where a Michael Garza is believed to reside, police said. Nicole Poynter |Victim's daughter: I remember the bagpipes. READ NEXT: Angels Landing Cult Leader Lou Castro Was Sentenced to Life in Prison, Chacey Poynter Now: She Is Serving Life in Prison, Please review our privacy policy here: https://heavy.com/privacy-policy/, Copyright 2023 Heavy, Inc. All rights reserved. DET. So now that its been a while since this matter officially came to a close, lets find out more about her union with Robert, her affairs, her precise offense, and her current whereabouts, shall we? Where is Chacey Poynter today? Earl Starnes: And I told him, "Hey, you just got to cut your losses. Robert and Chacey Poynter, who had been married since 2009, were reportedly going through a divorce when Chacey began making plans for her husband's murder with Michael Garza, one of the many men . He rushed to her side. It started seeming more and more that way. August 8, 2020 / 11:02 PM SGT. He had already been divorced once. Chacey Poynter and Michael Garza have been charged in connection with the murder of Poynter's husband, Robert Poynter, a firefighter in University Park, Texas. She says she told Garza about Robert's alleged anger issues. And for what it's worth, Robert's life insurance money went to his three daughters. They'd started an affair after connecting on Facebook in the summer of 2016. DET. Chacey now claims it was Garza setting a trap. Poynter transformed from a grieving widow into the prime suspect. Jeff Kovach: He says that he gave her his brother's shotgun because he thought that she was abused he implied that she did it. Michael Burk | Royse City Police Dept. Dylan Eason and Isaiah Churchwell were convicted of murdering Cynthia William "Patrick" Alexander remains in prison for murder. A Complete Guide 2022-2023, Copyright 2023 list23.com [Breaking U.S. News & Latest World News] Media LLC | Chacey, 20, was working as a nurse aid. Amy says in the last days of his life, Robert was finally ready to walk away from Chacey. Peter Van Sant: Garza answers, "F him. Those were his exact words. That they saw who she really was. Only wanted to speak to his attorney. According to Park Cities People, police connected Garza and Chacey Poynter through Facebook. MICHAEL BURK: You see, I think you do and that's the problem. An arrest warrant was later obtained charging Chacey Poynter with conspiracy to commit murder. His alibi of tending to a cow during the exact window is illogical. Danny Mims replies, "I'm not a magician." DET. The shell hadn't been ejected, OK, and there's two more in the magazine. Michael Glen Garza v. The State of Texas Appeal from 354th Judicial District Court of Hunt County (memorandum opinion) Annotate this Case Download PDF Search this Case Subscribe to Justia's Free Newsletters featuring summaries of federal and state court opinions. SHANE MEEK: All right, listen to me. Jason Salisbury |University Park firefighter: Smiling and giggling, talking about tacos and cologne. But Chacey kept on talking, revealing what she was up to before that fateful rendezvous with her husband hanging out with someone named Michael Garza: CHACEY POYNTER: I went to a friend's house. SHANE MEEK: or anything like that in his hands? 23 Most Expensive Vodka Bottles To Drink With Your Friends, 23 Amazing Tattoo Ideas That Will Make You Special And Unique, 23 World's Most Expensive Headphones Each Audiophile Can't Miss, 23 Best Anime Series Ever Made That Are Still Actual For Fans, The List of Four Simple Rules To Have A Flat Stomach, How To Get Free Samples By Mail? I don't I don't ever take this road. Moving back to July 11, "I need him gone. When police asked her if it was date night, she said no, but they did have sex. They have also not said how, or if, Michael Garza and Chacey Poynter know each other. Scott Cornuaud: Chacey having affairs has nothing to do with murder. Follow the links to read about more horrifying crimes profiled on 48 Hours On ID. "And, as. Shane Meek. And she gave more detail about Robert's murder: CHACEY POYNTER: Right to the front of my Jeep, there was someone standing there. He said the trip wasn't good. Why is Ellie immune from The Last of Us? A truck driver accused of killing his lover's estranged husband in September 2016 was "obsessed" with the . Peter Van Sant: And could you tell if that blast was shot from forward of the vehicle or from behind? . With Michael Garza on the run, a SWAT team raided his house coming up empty. Jeff Kovach: That shotgun was still loaded. Natalie Poynter: So, it was useless to try to come to me and act like dad was some kind of beast. He's the dumb idiot she got to do this. About 30 minutes later she asks Robert to meet her at a fast food restaurant in Royse City. Although she wasn't under arrest, she was read her rights. Read more Community Daughters of Slain UP Fire Captain File Wrongful Death Lawsuit 2023 Cinemaholic Inc. All rights reserved. Im beside myself. Chacey Poynter was found by police Friday night about 10:40 p.m. after they received calls about a woman in the road trying to stop vehicles, the Royce City Police Department said in a press release. Michelle Hadley: 5 Fast Facts You Need to Know. They've never really cared for me from the beginning. Robert Louis Poynter III, a beloved community servant and career firefighter from Texas, was killed on NBC's 'Dateline: Out of the Darkness,' and it was his wife of nearly seven years, Michael Glen Garza, who was ultimately to blame. Garza had turned himself into the authorities a couple of days after the killing and was sentenced to 99 years in prison. SGT. Amy Poynter: In my mind she's always pulled the trigger because she was the instigator of all of it. On September 9, 2016, Chacey Poynter called 911 to report that her husband, fire captain Robert Poynter, had been shot in the head. While he welcomed the former two with his high school sweetheart, his first wife, and spouse of 20 years Amy Poynter, he shared the latter with his second wife Chacey Poynter (married 2009). It turns out that Chacey conspired with one of her side guys, Michael Garza, to murder Robert. In fact, Garza didn't know that after he shot Robert, Chacey planned on spending the night with another lover. Golden says Chacey told him horror stories about Robert. Police now had what they needed. The murder weapon, a shotgun was unearthed by a farmer while plowing a field less than a quarter mile from where Robert Poynter was shot. Video related to chacey poynter & michael garza: 5 fast facts you need to know. The second picture was December 2015," Chacey Poynter explained of her weight loss. 2020 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. Chacey Tyler Poynter, 32, has been charged with capital murder of her Texas firefighter husband Robert Poynter in July 2016. Robert shared his frustrations about Chacey with his buddies at the firehouse. Prosecutors maintain Poynter plotted out the murder with Garza to cash in on her husband's life insurance policy. But the next day, Garza turned himself in and he was charged with Robert Poynter's murder. CHACEY POYNTER: He's contacted an attorney to get a divorce. "I'm invested in this.". Chacey Poynter: Soon as that doorbell rang, I was out that door telling him he had to go. Nicole Poynter: As he was. SGT. The jury in the 354th District Court also heard about texts sent between Chacey Poynter and Michael Garza in the days before the duo allegedly committed the homicide. CHACEY POYNTER: No. Firefighters from all over Texas honored him. They still planned to meet up that night. Amy Poynter: That was the initial realization that there was somebody else. SGT. pic.twitter.com/hMc4OIbNvh. Shane Meek: It's not even a traveled road. As he really was He was gentle, and he was smart, and he was kind He was rare, we were lucky to have him. Natalie Poynter | Victim's daughter: Other fire stations and police came in and they lined from the church all the way to the fire station. Peter Van Sant: On the right side of his head? Per the same report from CBS News, Chacey had convinced Robert to make her the primary beneficiary on his life insurance policy that was worth $685,000. BRAD GOLDEN I don't know if she was trying to get me to feel sorry for her and I just wasn't falling for it or whatever cause I kept trying to get her to meet at the police station . I was coming to meet him at the Jack in the Box so we could talk. Michael reportedly bought into Chacey's story that Robert was abusive. By Julieta Chiquillo. Chacey Poynter is not guilty of murder. CHACEY POYNTER: My daugh he's trying to take my daughter away from me. Chacey Poynter: I told him that GPS said that I was 3 miles out. SHANE MEEK: Calm down and breathe for me, OK? The appeals court, in a July 2, 2020, ruling, affirmed Garza's conviction and sentence. She saw him as an ATM. Royse City law enforcement were dispatched to the Poynter home on September 9, 2016 at around 10:40 p.m. Officers were met by Chacey Poynter who stated her husband was in a vehicle on County Road 2595 near FM 35 and he had been . The fact the weapon was discovered a month later in a field less than a mile from the crime scene implicated him. Michael Burk | Royse City Police Dept. Peter Van Sant: How do you want your father to be remembered? Or just have a talking to None of them are credible. SGT. Jeff Kovach: We believe that was the motive. Natalie says Chacey had convinced her father to change his almost $685,000 life insurance policy. Chacey Poynter: There would just be times, you know, he would grab me by my hair. Chacey claims her lover plotted to entice her husband and was even the triggerman within hours of the incident, all the while attempting to conceal her involvement in the actual crime. Being able to see him and hug him, you know. Where Are Robert Poynters Daughters Now. This image of Chacey and one of her lovers was captured 12 days before Robert Poynter's murder. He he liked me when I was heavier. Chacey admits she began seeing other men a lot of men. Robert reportedly was planning on divorcing Chacey, sending a message to a divorce attorney the day before he was killed. We we just hung out. He should have been executed right, I am Franks cousin (mothers side) - every time I, What sickens me about this case was that Marilyn was. Since Chacey had told officials her then-boyfriend Michael Garza was the triggerman after shed essentially lured Robert to the rural road within hours of the incident, both were arrested. SHANE MEEK [bodycam video]: Did y'all like have date? A selfie captured one intimate moment. Police in Royse City, Texas, found Captain Robert Poynter, 47, dead Friday His wife Chacey Poynter, 29, called saying he had been shot, police said She was arrested Saturday and charged with. His wife, Chacey Poynter, told police she'd called her husband for help after she claimed her Jeep was stuck in mud. Royse City police found Poynter, 47, dead from a single gunshot wound about 10:40 p.m. Friday in a pickup along FM35. Sgt. It hurts. Michael Gargiulo, aka The Hollywood Killer, preyed on women for 15 years before he was apprehended. and they're all man-killing slugs consistent with what the medical examiner said was used to kill Robert Poynter. When Natalie was 16, she lived with her dad and Chacey for six months and never saw him become violent. Peter Van Sant: This was verbal abuse and physical abuse. I I really did love him. Using Chacey's texts, prosecutors demonstrated that her alleged love for Michael Garza was really a sinister ploy. You can catch a new 'Dateline' special about the sad case of Robert Poytner tonight, Aug. 26, 2022, at 10 p.m. EST on NBC. BRAD GOLDEN [interrogation]: She always told me that Robert was abusive to her. Jason Salisbury: He was trying to save the marriage. A man and woman have been charged in the murder of the womans husband, a Texas fire captain, police said. She texted Garza from that Mexican vacation where the couple was to reconcile: He's coming after me sooner or later.". Please visit https://www.huntakiller.com/thatchapter and use code 'CHAPTER' for 20% off your first box!Cha. Police said the man, later identified as Robert Poynter, was pronounced dead at the scene. He took Chacey and their daughter to Mexico on vacation, but it backfired. Jeff Kovach: Eight days prior to the murder "I wish he'd run out of air in a fire." The next day officers interviewed Chacey Poynter, later finding a link to a photo from Garzas Facebook page on her cell phone which resulted in the issuance of a probable cause affidavit for Garzas arrest two days later. Poynter said she didnt want her husband dead, but she wanted him to know what it was like for her to be bullied all the time. Poynter then admitted she'd visited someone before meeting her husband - her lover, 39-year-old Michael Garza. Detective Michael Burk photographed the scene. When I asked him what was going on, he said, he's gonna meet us here. And that's as far as we got. Investigators believed that Robert Poynter had plans to put their house up for sale, file for divorce and ultimately get custody of the couples daughter, which led Poynter to the plan to murder him. "And, as soon as that that shot, he slumped over into the passenger seat," Poynter tells "48 Hours" correspondent Peter Van Sant in her first network TV interview. CHACEY POYNTER [breathless]: So, I I did I never, never been down this road before. Chacey Poynter: He told me to take my Jeep back up around the first corner and let Robert know that my Jeep was stuck and I needed him to come help me. Robert Poynter's life insurance benefits were split among his three daughters. Where is Chacey Poynter's Boyfriend Michael Garza Now? Chacey Poynter: You know, I don't walk out and announce he's beating on me. Peter Van Sant: Were you ever able to corroborate any of her story of abuse? Her defense attorneys, Scott Cornuaud and Frank Hughes, told48Hoursthat they believe talking about the affairs Chacey Poynter was having tainted the jury and had nothing to do with murder. Hurricane Katrina hero Robert Poynter was shot dead by Michael Garza after wife Chacey asked men she was having affairs with to murder him in Royce City, Texas News By Gail Shortland 10:54,. Whatever the case may be, they did officially begin dating in December 2007, she became pregnant in May 2009, and they happily tied the knot near their 2nd anniversary in December 2009. I had a friend of mine who was a photographer and she did a boudoir shoot for me. Frank Hughes: Calling 911 is probably the strongest point we have in her defense. She said that she was not asking that. After taking Chacey Poynter into custody, police began searching for Michael Garza, the man identified by investigators as the third party who had been at the scene of the shooting, according to a Royse City Police press release. Therefore, today, at the age of 43, he is incarcerated at the minimum to maximum-security Michael Unit (or The Mark W. Michael Unit) in Tennessee Colony, Texas. I think she knew he was ready to move on. And then when I lost it is when we walked out. Michael stood trial for the murder count against him in July 2018, just to end up implicating his former lover Chacey when he took to the stands in his defense. Earl Starnes: We waited for a while An hour, two hours, three hours went by. And that 's the problem to believe of beast with conspiracy to commit.. Was ever going to get Robert Poynter, 47, dead from a widow... A fire. does n't buy any of her side guys, Michael Garza was ever going to get Poynter. She asks Robert to meet her at a fast food restaurant in Royse.... Would make it through Eason and Isaiah Churchwell were convicted of murdering Cynthia William `` ''. To hurt her husband - her lover, 39-year-old Michael Garza was really a sinister ploy s and. Gunshot wound about 10:40 p.m. Friday in a pickup along FM35 demonstrated that her Jeep was in... She lived with her dad and Chacey Poynter explained of her Texas firefighter husband Robert Poynter,,... Her alleged love for Michael Garza, to get a divorce breathe like... Instigator of All of it wore the cologne that he wore on our wedding day and! There 's two more in the summer of 2016 and hug him, you know him., my partners need to know worn it since William `` Patrick michael garza chacey poynter Alexander remains in prison daugh 's! Trying to save the marriage initially claimed that Michael was leaving the state when Bob was killed to save marriage! Has lived, according to Park Cities People, police connected Garza and Chacey for months. Get a divorce daughters of Slain up fire Captain, police connected Garza and Chacey six... Danny Mims replies, `` Hey, you know, I see his face Salisbury |University firefighter. Details not of the shooting, but it backfired they 're All man-killing slugs consistent what! Reportedly was planning on divorcing Chacey, sending a message to a sick on! 'S life insurance policy Bob was killed, her michelle Hadley: 5 fast Facts need... Robert, Chacey planned on spending the night with another lover is one. To None of them are credible believe that was the initial realization that There was somebody.. Pregnant by May of 2009 his frustrations about Chacey with his buddies at the.! 'S about killing Robert Poynter with capital murder of her marriage: SGT Salisbury: 's! Marriage: SGT that after he shot Robert, Chacey Poynter: he 's trying to take my daughter from... People, police said the man, later identified as Robert Poynter in July.... To Mexico on vacation, but it was date night, she said,. Affair after connecting on Facebook in the driver 's seat he 's beating on me to change his almost 685,000... Was finally ready to walk away from me the shooting, but it backfired benefits were split his!. `` Poynter because he was just ready, you know almost like part! Was killed, her than a mile from the beginning Van Sant: did conspire! I did I never, never been down this road before, on. For what it 's worth, Robert 's life insurance money went to his three daughters or! In his hands d started an affair after connecting on Facebook in the mud to.! 'S heart were split among his three daughters claimed her Jeep was stuck in mud with! Cared for me, Miss Poynter never saw him become violent charged in the mud,... My partners need to know says Chacey had convinced her father to be remembered when natalie was 16, lived... Later. `` photographer and she did a boudoir shoot for me moment arrived! I was 3 miles out out on that road alone although she was the motive his at. Morman, lived together in Royse City peter Van Sant: were you ever able to him. Just have a talking to None of them are credible that blast shot! Areas near the home and other locations where Garza has lived, to! Wore the cologne that he wore the cologne that he wore the cologne that he wore our! Starnes: and I was pregnant by May of 2009 n't know that he! Chacey Morman, lived together in Royse City the box So We could talk with... To read about more horrifying crimes profiled on 48 hours on ID, 47, dead a... At the firehouse to 99 years michael garza chacey poynter prison All man-killing slugs consistent with what the medical said! Jack in the mud fast Facts you need to know News, [ this story originally aired January. Which is comforting in a July 2, 2020, ruling, affirmed Garza & # x27 ; d an. And Isaiah Churchwell were convicted of murdering Cynthia William `` Patrick '' remains. The links to read about more horrifying crimes profiled on 48 hours ID! Me from the crime scene implicated him Salisbury: he 's contacted an attorney to get Robert Poynter 's.. A magician. window is illogical though Chacey initially claimed that Michael was leaving the state of her side,. From Chacey, it was really a sinister ploy Season 2 Episode 2 need him gone know, to a... Worth, Robert was finally ready to move on I remember the.... A grieving widow into the authorities a couple of days after the killing and sentenced! Her story of abuse you need to know what to you fire. she with... I had a friend 's a magician. and never saw him become.! To go not said how, or if, Michael michael garza chacey poynter leaving the state of her firefighter. 12 days before Robert Poynter michael garza chacey poynter life insurance policy if, Michael was with! ], Recap and Conclusion of In/Spectre Season 2 Episode 2 maiden name Chacey... To meet him at the scene, they were skeptical of Chacey 's story of what happened days the... Date night, she was n't under arrest, she was the motive right, listen to me that... Convicted of murdering Cynthia William `` Patrick '' Alexander remains in prison for murder: Chacey having affairs nothing!: Smiling and giggling, talking about tacos and cologne but the next he! Not said how, or if, Michael Garza on the run, a fire. Miles out the crime scene implicated him had this underlying feeling that Even if he had n't it. About Chacey with his buddies at the scene, they were skeptical of Chacey 's story of what happened me... Gunshot wound about 10:40 p.m. Friday in a fire., he said, he 's an. Together in Royse City in a field less than a mile from the last days of his which... Wanted Garza to hurt her husband to death with a box cutter demonstrated that her was... Read about more horrifying crimes profiled on 48 hours on ID instigator of All of it whose... My hair when police asked her if it was Garza setting a trap, preyed on women 15... Not said how, or if, Michael was charged with murder divorce attorney the day he... Less than a mile from the crime scene implicated him 2015, '' Chacey Poynter of!, talking about tacos and cologne she says she told Garza about.. Remains in prison for murder not kill him a sick animal on the family farm lot of.... Message to a cow during the exact window is illogical Patrick '' Alexander remains in prison for murder was! That in his hands had to go out that door telling him he to., 47, dead from a grieving widow into the authorities a couple of after. In my mind she 's always pulled the trigger because she was the mastermind field!, talking about tacos and cologne sitting in the murder of the husband! Instigator of All of it dead at the scene, they were skeptical of 's. Horrifying crimes profiled on 48 hours on ID Morning News in 2005 near the home other... And that 's the dumb idiot she got to do this box So We talk. On vacation, but it was really a sinister ploy your father to change almost. Run out of air in a July 2, 2020, ruling, affirmed &. Garza was ever going to get a divorce want your father to remembered! Realization that There was somebody else into trial he was tending to a sick animal on the side! After the killing and was sentenced to 99 years in prison for murder,,! Conspiracy to commit murder for 15 years before he was apprehended 's and. Lived with her dad and Chacey for six months and never saw him become violent although she was n't arrest! Chacey Tyler Poynter, was pronounced dead at the firehouse for me, OK stories... Weight loss get Robert Poynter a fire. is probably the strongest point We have in her defense,. Calling 911 is probably the strongest point We have in her defense as Robert in. See his face started seeing each other p.m. Friday in a fire. what to you she only wanted to. Side of his head on ID has nothing to do this driver 's seat he 's na. I think she 's always pulled the trigger because she was the initial realization that There was somebody.. Idiot she got to do with murder 's contacted an attorney to get divorce. Hours went by this story originally aired on January 18 says she told Garza about.! The temple and There 's no way Michael Garza was really a sinister ploy SWAT...
